The best compost includes a balanced mix of green materials (rich in nitrogen) and brown materials (rich in carbon). This combination ensures optimal decomposition and nutrient availability for plants.
A diverse mix helps create a rich, crumbly compost that supports healthy plant growth and improves soil structure. Aim for a variety of textures and types to promote a thriving ecosystem within your compost pile!
Check out this Gardeners World article on great types of compost bins to find the one thats right for you.

20 Items to Add to Compost Pile
- Fruit and Vegetable Scraps
- Rich in nitrogen and help break down into nutrient-rich compost.
- Coffee Grounds
- Provide nitrogen and improve soil structure.
- Eggshells
- Add calcium, which is essential for plant health.
- Grass Clippings
- High in nitrogen; they decompose quickly and add bulk.
- Leaves
- Provide carbon and create air pockets in the compost.
- Wood Chips
- High in carbon; help aerate the compost and slow down decomposition.
- Plant Trimmings
- Add organic matter and nutrients as they decompose.
- Hay or Straw
- Provides carbon and helps maintain aeration.
- Shredded Paper
- Adds carbon; be sure it’s non-glossy and free of toxic inks.
- Cardboard
- Great source of carbon; should be shredded or torn into small pieces.
- Hair
- Adds nitrogen; breaks down slowly but provides essential nutrients.
- Tea Bags (non-plastic)
- Rich in nitrogen; just remove any metal staples.
- Nut Shells
- Provide carbon and minerals; avoid those that are treated or salted.
- Wood Ash
- Adds potassium and raises pH, but use sparingly to avoid alkalinity.
- Sawdust
- High in carbon; mix well to avoid compacting.
- Plant-Based Biodegradable Items
- Breakdown quickly and enrich compost (e.g., certain food containers).
- Bedding from Herbivorous Pets
- Composed of organic materials; safe for compost.
- Crushed Sea Shells
- Provide calcium and other minerals.
- Old Potting Soil
- Contains nutrients and beneficial microorganisms.
- Compostable Utensils and Plates
- Made from plant materials; break down over time.
20 Items to Avoid Adding to Compost Pile
- Meat and Fish Scraps
- Attract pests and create odors; slow to decompose.
- Dairy Products
- Can lead to odor issues and attract pests.
- Oils and Grease
- Slow decomposition and can create a smelly compost pile.
- Diseased Plants
- Can spread pathogens to your garden.
- Weeds with Seeds
- Seeds can survive and infest your garden when spread.
- Invasive Plant Species
- Can spread their roots and outcompete native plants. (Think Bamboo)
- Pet Waste (from carnivorous animals)
- May contain harmful pathogens and parasites.
- Chemical-treated Wood
- Chemicals can leach into compost and harm plants.
- Non-biodegradable Materials
- Items like plastics and metals don’t decompose.
- Citrus Peels
- High acidity can disrupt the composting process if added in large quantities.
- Onions and Garlic
- Can inhibit the growth of beneficial bacteria, and deter earth worms necessary for breaking down materials.
- Coal Ash
- May contain harmful substances and metals.
- Synthetic Fertilizers
- Can disrupt the microbial balance in compost.
- Colored or Glossy Paper
- May contain harmful inks and chemicals.
- Large Branches or Logs
- Slow to decompose; better suited for a separate compost method.
- Sick Plants
- Can introduce diseases into the compost.
- Uncooked Grains or Pasta
- Attract pests and can cause odor issues.
- Processed Foods
- Often contain preservatives and additives harmful to compost.
- Human Hair or Nails
- Decompose very slowly and may contain chemicals.
- Old or Treated Wood Products
- Can introduce toxic substances into your compost.

If you’re interested in the benefits of composting but don’t have the space, look into services like Black Earth Compost, who will pick up scraps, compost for you, and return the finished compost.
Adding the right materials will create a nutrient-rich compost, while avoiding harmful items will keep your compost healthy and effective. Happy composting!
